Tax Returns and a Legitimate Purpose


Dansko Women's Meadow Ankle Boot - Choose SZ color, , , , , , ,

The Ways and Means Committee of the United States House of Representatives Dansko Women's Raina Ankle Bootthat the I.R.S. turn over President Trump’s tax returns and related information from the past six years. The Committee’s Chairman, Rep. Richard Neal, notes that the reason for his request is  to examine audit procedures for a president.

William S. Consovoy, retained by President Trump to represent him on this matter, responded to the request with DANSKO Womens Tamara Black Leather Casual Clogs shoes Sz 35 = 4.5 - 5 DK-152 sent to the U.S. Treasury Department, advising the I.R.S. not to turn over the returns. He argues in that letter that President Trump has a privacy interest in his tax returns, which should be protected, and that the Ways and Means Committee has no legitimate reason for requesting  them. He claims that the reasons put forth by Neal are disingenuous and meant to hide his true motivation, which is purely political.

The congressional authority to request tax returns is codified in Dark Brown Leather Lizard Cap Toed 13 NOCONA 7312 Western Cowboy Boots Sz 8.5D, which reads in part:

“Upon written request from the chairman of the Committee on Ways and Means of the House of Representatives, the chairman of the Committee on Finance of the Senate, or the chairman of the Joint Committee on Taxation, the Secretary shall furnish such committee with any return or return information specified in such request . . . .”

Emphasis is added here to demonstrate that, generally, the I.R.S. does not have the discretion to refuse a request for tax records from Congress. However, as Ross Garber points out Darkwood pinkwood Womens Ankle Boots Water Resistant Faux Fur Walking shoes, the Supreme Court has held that Congress exceeds its constitutional authority when requesting documents without a legitimate legislative purpose. He predicts a lengthy legal battle to determine whether such a legitimate reason actually exists, which Congress will ultimately  lose by reason of lack of legal authority or eventual mootness. Still, all is not lost. Garber points out that if the returns are not ultimately turned  over, then they could become a future article of  impeachment, for failure to turn over tax returns for improper reasons.



, , DC Men's Nyjah Vulc Black bluee Sneakers shoes, , Dc Pure High Top Wc Wnt Mens Footwear shoes - Navy Khaki All Sizes, , , Dc shoes Evan Hi Le J shoes Ww0 White White 42.5 EU (10.5 US 8.5 UK), , , ,

Representative Al Green has expressed his Dc shoes Heathrow Tx Le J shoes Na0 Dark Navy 37 EU (6 US 4 UK) articles of impeachment this year. He introduced articles DC shoes Men PLAYER LE - black gum (BGM) - Klassiker, citing Trump’s bigotry and racism as evidence of his lack of integrity and unfitness for office, and, forcing a vote on the floor, summoned the support of 60 democrats. He is not dissuaded by Attorney General Barr’s summary of Mueller’s report, and the lack of evidence of conspiracy between the President and the Russian government. He maintains that Trump is unfit for office because of his discriminatory decisions and statements.

Green’s position is similar, if more narrow, to that which has been put forth by Professor Bowman who presents  “a view of impeachment as an essential tool in the case of a president who consistently violates legal and behavioral norms essential to the preservation of American constitutional order.”

green.jpgDrew Angerer/Getty Images

Barr Releases Summary of Mueller’s Report

Décolleté Salvatore Ferragamo vara women - Pelle (VARACT06921)
DKNY Briana Womens Trainers Black, UK 5 EU 38 LN36 44


, Demonia 14I Vegan Black 4 Buckle Boots Gothic Biker Punk Combat 4 5 6 7 8 9, Demonia 4.5 Platform Green Hologram Open Back Harness Stud Boots Club Glam 6-12, Demonia Black PU 3.25 Platform 5 Buckled Mens Knee Boots TRASHVILLE-518 B PU, , DEMONIA CREEPER-206 Women's Vegan Gothic Heart O-Ring Platform Creepers shoes, Demonia EMILY-318 Women's Black Patent Platform Lace-Up w Ball Gag Ankle Boots, , , Demonia Kera 08 Ladies Black Wedge Platform Vegan Lolita Double Strap shoes, , DEMONIA Poison-105 5 Wedge PF Goth Punk Alternative Platform Boots, DEMONIA Sexy Punk Gothic Lolita Platform Strappy T-Strap Pump shoes TOR600 BVL, Demonia Stack 301 Cyber Goth Gogo 7 Stacked Platform Knee High Boot, , DEMONIA V-CRE571 BVL Mens Black Punk Goth Zipper 2 Platform Creeper Ankle Boots, Demonia Women's RIVAL-300 302 303 307 309 315 400 404 Combat Motorcycle Boots, Derby pour Homme GEOX men SNAKE, color brown

Attorney General William Barr has released a four-page summary of Special Counsel Robert Mueller’s report. In it he announced that Mueller did not find sufficient evidence to establish the President Trump’s campaign conspired with Russian groups to manipulate the results of the 2016 election. Additionally, he writes that Mueller did not make a recommendation as to whether the President should be charged with obstruction of justice, but rather presented evidence on both sides of the issue and deferred to the Attorney General. Bar and Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein have decided not to pursue indictment of the President on that charge. Barr notes that he intends to release as much of the report as will not violate Derbys pour femme STONEFLY CLYDE 14, color black, governing the release of grand jury information. After the release of Mueller’s findings, the House of Representatives will have to decide whether they believe the evidence is sufficient for impeachment.


Donald J Pliner Elio Brown Suede Ankle Chukka Boots Men's US Size 10.5 M